196. When the Lawsuit Comes: Dr. Gita Pensa on Shame, Survival, and Physician Support

Malpractice litigation is one of the most feared and least discussed realities in medicine, yet for many physicians, it is not a remote possibility but an eventual risk of practice.

Dr. Gita Pensa joins Drs. Joanne Sotelo and Erin Hurley to explore the psychological toll of being named in a lawsuit, from shame, isolation, and identity threat to burnout, trauma, and even suicide risk. Drawing from her own experience surviving a 12-year malpractice case and facing litigation again, Dr. Pensa shares how support, self-compassion, legal understanding, and practical preparation can change the way physicians move through these cases. The conversation is both deeply human and highly actionable, offering a needed call to replace silence with openness, skill-building, and culture change in medicine.

Key Takeaways To Listen For

• Malpractice litigation is often experienced as an identity threat, not just a legal event, because it attacks a physician's sense of competence, purpose, and worth
• Shame and silence make the experience far more dangerous, pushing physicians toward isolation at a time they most need support
• Emotional support matters, but physicians also need concrete litigation skills and a working understanding of the legal process to move from catastrophe into preparation
• Letting trusted people in can be protective on every level, helping physicians stay grounded in who they are rather than what the lawsuit implies
• Changing the culture around litigation will require peer support, education, institutional leadership, and more honest public conversation about the realities of medical risk

"What I know is that emotional preparedness and skill preparedness goes a long way in terms of how it is that you can rise to meet the challenge." — Dr. Gita Pensa

About Dr. Gita Pensa: Gita Pensa, MD, FAAEM, is an emergency physician, Adjunct Associate Professor of Emergency Medicine at Brown University, and a nationally recognized expert on malpractice litigation stress and physician litigation support.

She is the creator and host of the open-access podcast curriculum Doctors and Litigation: The L Word, widely used in medicine, law, and the medical liability insurance industry. Dr. Pensa consults with insurers, hospital systems, and defense attorneys, and maintains a national coaching practice preparing and supporting medical defendants through litigation. She is also the creator of the LEAP (Litigation Education and Performance) courses, licensed by numerous hospital systems and medical liability insurers.

Dr. Pensa is a managing editor at EM: RAP (Emergency Medicine Reviews and Perspectives), a former editor of the Academic Emergency Medicine research podcast, and a consultant for the second season of Emmy-winning medical drama The Pitt. Her work has been featured in Time, NPR, SXSW, and the PBS documentary A World of Hurt: How Medical Malpractice Fails Everyone.

Connect with Dr. Gita Pensa:

Website: http://doctorsandlitigation.com

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/gita-pensa-m-d-693557189/

Use coupon code MEANING100 to save $100 on the LEAP for Clinicians (Litigation Education and Performance) course. Eligible for 16 hours of Category 1 CME while learning the legal process, skills, and mindset to understand healthcare litigation.

Enroll here: https://www.doctorsandlitigation.com/offers/r68JPnuD?coupon_code=MEANING100

Organizations interested in licensing or group discounts can learn more at: https://www.doctorsandlitigation.com/

Connect With Us

Find every episode at https://www.createmeaninginmedicine.com

▶️ Watch on YouTube: https://youtube.com/@createmeaninginmedicine

🎧 Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/create-meaning-in-medicine/id1752701820